19 May 2018

Screening for breast cancer: Some inconvenient truths.

Most of you will be well aware of the controversy over the value of mammographic screening.

To help you, I have written a detailed account of the issues together with the best advice I can offer you for your health maintenance which you can find on this link:

Screening for Breast Cancer by Mammography

In summary:

  1. Screening for breast cancer by mammography does not save lives and does not save breasts.
  2. For every breast cancer death avoided, there is excess mortality from other causes because of the over-treatment of over-diagnosed “pseudo-cancers”.
  3. Whenever a population of women is screened for breast cancer, the mastectomy rate increases because of the high detection rate of multi-focal duct carcinoma in-situ. (DCIS)
  4. The increased rate of detection of DCIS is not followed by a reduction in the incidence of more aggressive forms of breast cancer.
  5. The good news is that mortality from breast cancer has been falling rapidly over the last 15-20 years, thanks to improvements in treatment.
  6. As a result, deaths from breast cancer have dropped down the ranking of common causes of death for women in the Western world.
  7. The commonest causes of death for women are in order of importance:
    1. Dementia
    2. Heart disease
    3. Strokes
    4. Lung cancer
    5. Chronic bronchitis
  8. In this essay, I explain how you can carry out your own risk assessment for these serious conditions and to what extent you can help yourselves.
  9. Women often over-estimate their risks of getting breast cancer; on average, the 5-year risk for pre-menopausal women is 0.5% and for post-menopausal women, 1.0%
  10. For those who still feel they might benefit from screening, I recommend the attached information leaflet developed by the independent Nordic Cochrane Centre.
Share this article

Professor Michael Baum's blog posts

The screening paradox

Breast screening and self examination? Is breast screening bad for you? Professor Michael Baum shares a chapter of his latest book.

Read More

Screening for breast cancer by mammography

Read here about the benefits and harms of attending a screening programme for breast cancer. With documentation for the facts and figures.

Read More

Discover More

Menopause Resources

Find a menopause specialist, download our symptom checker, tips on preparing for your GP visit and so much more.

Menopause Support for Employers

Speak to us about how we can help you support employees affected by menopause symptoms.

Join our Facebook Community

The original home of The Latte Lounge - our private group of more than 25,000 women discussing all things midlife.

Note: This site is no longer actively updated with new content. Health information provided here is for archival purposes - always check with a qualified healthcare professional for current medical guidance.

magnifiercross-circle